@Markz
711 sounds good, I'm always good for a slurpee
@stillgoing
Thanks for the advice, and feel free to use the thread to post your thoughts. It's important to think about these things. I'm not sure if I agree with you or maybe I'm misunderstanding you. It sounds like you're saying that if I/we
reallyunderstood what the purpose of life was, I/we wouldn't struggle as much since we would be so involved in living life as it's meant to be lived.
I'm probably misunderstanding something, but isn't this basically the mussar approach to fighting lust? "If you only knew how important learning was" or "if you only knew how damaging this is to ourselves/ the world" etc. Aren't we always going to be human beings with the free will to live as we choose, no matter how much clarity we have at a given time (maybe that's what you meant about it still being there, just lessened)? With me at least, the clarity is there for a little bit and then goes away like everything else. Or, at the very least, isn't the process of appreciating what life is truly about a lifetime endeavor? I'm not 98 yet
, but I hope that by the time I get there I'll be living life as seriously as I should.
Also, I know that people might say that I'm in denial or something, but I definitely struggle with lust (although I'm not sure if I fall into the addict category, but I've heard that this is a black hole of a question) and my life has a lot of meaning. I'm really pretty happy with my life, I have a wonderful, supportive family and am pretty happy about how I spend my time (barring pornography of course). Things could always be better, but I have a tremendous amount to be thankful to Hkb"h for and my life is good and meaningful.
In terms of my life, the issue started when my life had less meaning and it definitely could have been why I was drawn in in the first place. At that point of my life I was unhappy with life in general and I'm sure that porn and masturbation acted as ways to "solve" those issues.
I think that my use of pornography and masturbation these days is more or less a (deeply engrained) habit from those days of my life when I "needed" it much more. That's not to say that it's not much more difficult to control when I'm having a bad day or whatever, just that on a day to day basis it's more or less of a habit and not satisfying some deep existential concern (although I'm some level I'm sure it is, as you point out).
These days it's more to relieve the "itch" than anything else (for the most part). For some people around here, the lust was literally destroying their lives and was uncontrollable. For me, it was a once a day thing and had been that way for years and hadn't been getting worse at all. Lehavdil, if I wasn't frum it wouldn't be wildly different than having a habit of having a donut a day. It's unhealthy, it might make you feel a little gross after, it might make you a little overweight, but it's not going to kill you and it's not destroying your life so just worry about other things. The main reason why I'm trying to stop is because it's assur and the side benefits are tangential.
This post/ ramble has been going on for a while and I'm realizing that this may be a part of my problem. Isn't GYE's motto about "hitting bottom while still on top" ? Maybe I just don't feel like it's such a terrible thing or something like that. I
don't feel like it's destroyed my life. Is that feeling that you've hit the bottom necessary for a true recovery?
If it is, then what's the eitza here? I can learn about how destructive pornography and masturbation are to my neshama and the world, or focus on all the bad things on my life and blame them on my masturbation. Somehow, I don't feel like these are very healthy approaches. They're likely to cause serious depression and yiush which are exactly what I/ anyone doesn't need.
Wow, stillgoing, you really got me going
! I haven't thought this through like this and I'm really grateful for the prompting. It's really helped me get a little more clarity than I had before. Anyway, I'm sure you have a different take on much of what I've said and look forward to hearing your (and others) perspective.