Dov wrote:
Dear Obbermottel (but never oiverbottel),
Thanks for sharing your own powerlessness with me! And my answer to you is "yes, and no".
As I keep saying, I am not a guru, nor an expert. All I can share with you is my experience - it is the SA way. And in my experience yes - I ask Him to take it away, dump the entire struggle on Him to alleviate from me, and it works. Period. Tehillim says, "Sh'lach al Hashem y'hov'cho, vHu yichalkelecho," and it means just that.
But I said "yes and no." The "no" part is this:
I was never successful at living free of sex with myself (and all my other forms of lusting and acting out), by doing that in a vaccum. My surrender was fake, fake, fake for years in yeshivah, marriage/kollel, etc....until I finally took the actions of true surrender. Those actions were:
1- Going to meetings, and not wimpy 'phone talk sessions' where I am not really there with real people, but rather, safely and comfortably hiding behind a telephone. Though I have heard of people being sober that way and believe that it is possible (just as I believe that the 12 steps are not necessary for all people and some people out there actually can beat this addiction with willpower or mussar or even just getting married - very unlikely, but who am I to say "it is impossible!"?). But as I have no personal evidence that it would have worked for me, so I cannot advise it to anyone else with confidence. If I did, that would be making myself some sort of teacher, rather than just a recovering Pervert that Hashem is using to help others - I'd be the expert then, doling out my advice, and I would fall flat on my face. And I would lose my sobriety. And for me, that means I'd die for certain. That is the 12 th step - sharing, not telling. People here generally do not even see the difference on their radar, so they read my sharing of experience and take it as 'telling and teaching'....too bad for them.
So, maybe you can do it just between you, your G-d, and the 'forum'. I do not know.
2- Having a sponsor and hanging around with really, truly recovering men like me - whether they were Yidden or not. What I needed more than anything else was to learn how to depend on my own G-d. And I learned that from my Catholic sponsor and from my other not-at-all-frum recovering Yidden-friends (and from other recovering goyim at the meetings) as much as from other recovering frum yidden who were in the meetings. And the input from those people was far, far, more essential to saving my sobriety, my yidishkeit, my marriage, and my life than was the input from the rabbis and roshei yeshivah I had over years of frum life. For those rebbis were not crazy addicts like me, were they? So how could I expect them to teach me how to really depend on G-d? They didn't need Him as I did! Of course, those rebbis who had gone through real suffering or loss R"l, could have helped me perhaps....it's all the same. For at some point in the trip, when addicts are really giving up our precious porn, fantasy, and masturbation, it feels like we will die without it. It is suffering and loss.
That's poshut. And again, hard to do with just virtual relationships on a forum.
3- I needed to have people to call up whenever I felt (excuse me for lack of a better word) 'horny'. And I needed to actually call them up and admit it befeirush - if they were smart, they'd respond with their own weakness rather than warning me "don't do it! Gevalt! It's osur! You'll be sorry!"....or other drivel that I had already been telling myself for a decade with no result at all...
Sharing our weakness and sharing our dependence on Power Greater than ourselves with each other is where the magic is. We get that by doing it for eachother as the hopeless addicts we really are