waydown wrote on 23 Feb 2016 18:34:
Working Guy,
Your analysis is defintley a thought provoking one. I never thought about your idea. So I can't respond yet. It deifntely seems contradictory to the 12 steps idea or the notion that lusters sare selfish people. But then again you can argue that based on your theory, it really is a selfish mida. Because no midda is good to an extreme. So one you run one way the body pulls you the other way. I am am confused and don't really make sense. As I said it needs thought but I do like the concept.
As a side note they do say that they yetzer hara for zenus does come from the mida of chesed. so maybe there is a connection.
Let me explain it a little more, and it's good for me too to review it. People are supposed to have a healthy balance of self-interest and care for others. When one is secure in their own needs, they are able to give to others and care for them in a healthy way.
R' Shimon Shkop points this out in his introduction to Shaarei Yosher. Hillel says "If I am not for myself, who is? But if I am only for myself, then who will be?" R' Shkop says that it is important for us to have self-interest, and use that self interest to expand our sense of self to include those around you.
So, I have to love myself first, then make my spouse a part of me, and then my family is a part of me, and the circle gets bigger. But where it starts is with your self. He explains that "ve'ahavta lereiacha kamocha" indicates that you have to love yourself in order to love your friend. Once you know how to properly love yourself, you can expand that to others.
Many addicts (using that term generally whether you consider yourself an addict or not) don't have enough self love or self care, and care about others before they care for themselves. But what happens to their own needs? Out of some sense of self deprivation, what happens is an extreme reaction- which IS selfish and jives with the twelve steps completely- of focusing on their own pleasure by acting out.
These same people who have been successful in negating their own needs in regular matters find it near impossible when it comes to sex, drugs, alcohol, or the addiction of their choice b/c the pleasure is so great.
That's how I've seen it play out within my own experience, and with others that I know. It might be something to explore, but again, only you know your own experiences.