thank you chevra for responding, i am grateful for the feedback.
Shlomo24 wrote:
lavi wrote:
true true, and i never said that the connection with Hashem is the cure-all to addiction problems. what i said was the underlying theme of the WHY i should recover, for me is a reglious matter.
that being said, of course it recommended to use sensible recovery tools such as 12 steps, or many of the other options gye has so nicely made available.
in fact, i honestly doubt if it is possible to recover without the right tools. remember, there is a setup why the addict fell to addiction in the first place, and simply "deciding" to work on his spirituality more, i don't think will work.
but if one uses the right tools AND in my case, makes the cause a religious one, it may increase chances of success.
i love you all
i think that connection to my higher power is what keeps me sober, and nothing else. granted the 12 steps pave the way for connection. dr. carl jung said in terms of AA that "spirituality fixes addiction" or something to that extent.
not sure i understand your position. connection to a higher power, let's say is defined as davening,learning,mitzvos,[meditating?]. are you saying that none of the other tools work for you? but you "grant" 12 steps? to pave the way? and taphsic method, sa, 90 days etc... are useless for you? maybe you should "grant" the forums as well, after all you are posting here?
at least you can understand the others who have been helped by different methods.
yirashamayim,
cordnoy wrote:
lavi, the white book talks all about the connection to God with which we are missin'
recovery is about findin' Him again.
Addiction is lookin' for that union.
but we were lookin' for love in all the wrong places.
bhatzlachah
cordnoy is right on the money. Recovery means connection to Hashem. It may not have the wrappings and trappings of our classic yeshiva education but it is right in line with the essence of emunah and bitachon.
Also lavi writes"the idea of serenity/stability/recovery, being the most important thing in the world, doesn't work for me. i need it to be a religious issue, or it doesn't matter so much to me. life is only as valueable as my connection with Hashem."
How in the world can we live and be successful in gasmius or ruchnuis if lust is in control? Sobriety is the the aleph-beis of life. As cordnoy stated before if life is unmanageable the in essence there is no life. We have become the walking dead. Haven't we all, by our efforts in recovery, connected to Hashem in a way we never had before. For me the raw honesty, the working on humility, the helping of others...
Whatever I was before I am certainly better today in untold ways because of this "idea of serenity/stability/recovery" that you so flippantly refer to.
The ladder to ruchnius is staring you in the face and you are ignoring it because of its
odd(goyish) looking packaging".
"Al tistakel bakankan..." עכ'ל
lavi responds:
for your info, the reason why i was being careful when i wrote my post, is that a long time ago there was a big discussion on this very point. should we recover for religious reasons or not, and most off the chevra then said, they felt it would be better not to. in fact our dear friend cordnoy, was among them. if he has changed his mind, or simply quoting a different view from the white book, remains to be seen.
please note i never implied that recovery cannot help spirituality , rather the point was:
should religion be our underlying reason for recovery. is "life" the main goal or religion?
if one sees all methods of recovery as religious steps, i think it is great. what i "flippantly" flipped was the other side of the coin, that there are others that don't see it that way, that means they find it counterproductive to view recovery in a religious way.