My Rebbi had a similar position to my mother in regards to where I stand in all this. Basically, my Rebbi holds that I am, at the very most, a regular guy with a somewhat more powerful Yezter Hara, and at the very least, I may be just like everyone else. I have never allowed myself to view real porn. I do not masturbate. I would never come close to doing some of the things that many of my fellow GYEers have engaged in.
Plus, he pointed out that by nature, I am someone who tends to dissect and examine my inner world and feelings in every area of life, and it is quite reasonable to assume that while my lusting is not anything unusual, I have made it into this raging monster inside my own head only because I am so caught up in my feelings and in my desire to be an eved Hashem. My Rebbi believes that if I knew for an absolute fact that every other bochur and man in the world was struggling exactly as I am, that it wouldn't bother me nearly as much. I struggle with ridifas hakavod, with kinah, with bittul Torah, and with lust. They all need to be understood, worked on and controlled. But my obsession with my lust problems may be the very source of my struggle. If I could just let things slide, without making myself do anything drastic or life-changing, I should be fine. Of course there's tons to gain from 12-step and the like, but for me it may be better to just take a chill pill and deal with this struggle in the same way that I deal with the other shortcomings Hashem has challenged me with.
Another ha'arah that both my LCSW mother and TCYS* Rebbi both came up with individually, is that my enthusiasm in regards to my involvement in GYE and recovery is itself a manifestation of my need to experience my lust -- a totally healthy behavior. However, constant reading and posting on the forums may not be an absolute necessity for me in order to maintain my kedusha.
The fact is that the only reason why I've been clean from internet shmutz for 154 days now is GYE. I've learned many incredible tools and lessons from being active on the forums and from reading the handbook and other GYE material. It would be foolish to think that I should just forget it all. But I think I do need to lessen my participation in some of these topics and discussions.
I am considering making an appointment with a certain Rav who has a lot of experience in helping bochurim navigate lust issues, to see if he agrees with this opinion. However, at this point I believe that I should follow the advice and hadracha given to me by the two people in my life that know me the best --my Rebbi and my mother-- and allow myself to relax a bit in my obsession with defeating a perceived lust addiction.
Let me reiterate that the only reason I have gotten to this point in understanding myself and the nature of my struggle, is because of the incredible people of GYE. The oilam on the forums was an inspiration to me long before I joined, and will continue to be a chizuk for me for my entire life.
I'll still be around, certainly over the rest of bein hazmanim, when boredom and loneliness are common and often create very challenging nisyonos. But I do need to follow the advice of my mentors and take a step back from the deep level of involvement and participation that I've become accustomed to ever since I joined GYE. Again, this move is part of my journey to success that began with GYE, not a revolt against it.
May all of you choshuve, heileger, special Yidden continue to grow and to find what works for you in winning the battle against this most difficult struggle, and may Hashem bentch all of you with bracha, hatzlacha, and recovery.
*Talmud Chacham Yerei Shamayim