E-Tek wrote on 13 Jun 2012 18:35:
Try to imagine the greatest love that exists on this earth- it's a parable to Hashem's love for you, so that you can better understand Hashem's love for you. All relationships in this world are mosholim for our relationship with the Ribono Shel Olam.
When a child runs across the street, does that minimize the love of the parent for the child? Not in the least. Low grades? Nope. And the parent doesn't even KNOW what goes on in the kid's mind, that he was depressed at his progress and couldn't study. Hashem knows you, he knows how hard it was, and he loves you... If He is disappointed about your failure, he still wants you to succeed, and He is willing to help anytime you reach out. He loves you. Believe it.
And, we at the forum love you too (on a smaller, mortal scale), and want to see you succeed.
B'Ahava,
Meir
And
that explains exactly why Hashem forgiving
you has nothing to do with Him loving
you or
not
loving
you.
His love for you and me is not like our love of another person...nor even like our love for Him. Our love is usually based on our recognizing virtue in another, or as a result of getting something precious from them, like approval or love. We come to love Hashem, as Rambam clearly writes, by recognizing and thinking about
His virtue and greatness.
But His love (just like everything else 'about' Him) is not a result of anything. It's intrinsic. His Love of you has nothing whatsoever to do with your deeds. It is permanent and total, unchanged by anything forever. Forgiveness of a person is only possible if you love them in some way - for Hashem this is not so at all. As the gemora says He naturally forgives and the business of "
If a person is ashamed of their sin, they are forgiven immediately (gm' Brachos)" just means that Hashem withholds the 'payoff' of their being forgiven until putting it into action would not harm them further. Clearly if you let someone
know they are forgiven and erase the results of the cheit even
before they take any serious action to change, they won't take the entire issue seriously and they will just keep sinning more and more and messing their lives up by being a loser.
Now, if you believe that the only
real 'damage' that results from masturbating yourself is the fact that G-d punishes you for it...then you are way off-base here and none of this will make much sense to you, of course. Because it becomes circular: "I need forgiveness because I did some random thing that He says I must not do...and He is the one who I beg forgiveness from," is just plain crazy. It explains a good degree of the OCD-nuttiness that goes on here regarding sexual sins and, ironically, reduces it to the same self-centered obsessiveness as all
other brands of OCD.
So the reason I wrote the comment (3 years ago) that Shmulyz18 commented on now just above, was in response to the following post before it by Some_guy (Elias) from 3 years ago:
You are also saying that Hashem loves everyone no matter what they do. I am reading a book on Chasidic thinking that says that a lot. I just don't understand how that can be possible. How can He just forgive me for doing this disgusting, immoral sin. I read in a few book that this sin is the worst one in the torah. I just not good enough to deserve compassion. Like a few days ago. As soon as I got out of bed, even befor washing my hands or using the rest room, I went to my family's computer. I was not able to even slow myself down. How can He just forget about that like it didn't matter?
Make sense now? The fellow is fixated on his performance for G-d. He is stuck in the thinking that everything is a test, that he is the Actor on The Great Stage, and sees G-d as the unfortunate cosmic Ringleader going crazy because his pets are screwing everything up, fouling-up His plans. He is set to punish them now and teach them a lesson!
Gevalt, this is just not the Truth. At least, it isn't the perspective any mature oved Hashem
I know walks around with. It's based on a view that is self-centered, not G-d-centered.
And I will repeat below what I posted 3 years ago to Some_Guy(Elias) above - see it in light of the clear, terse, and honest posts here by Skeptical, please. And you will see they are saying the very same things he suggests but with more detail.
And what did Some_Guy do with those ideas then?
How long is this same battle going to be waged back and forth with the same ideas being bantered about, the same suggestions being made, and the same arguments a month-or-year-later all over again? How will anyone finally be convinced?
I say it will run around indefinitely - until the missing ingredient is finally found. And I think that ingredient is finally starting to let go of the self-centered view that
we all have as a left-over from our childhoods.
The Holy Grail of GYE: 'finally figuring it out', is not the answer. Intellect and thinking will not solve this. Not by a long shot.
Rather, as AA simply puts it in the sweet Member Stories: '
Acceptance is the Answer'.
The missing ingredient for me, that makes all my recovery fail or work, is my willingness to
grow up.