wantoimprove wrote on 12 Apr 2016 20:09:
Shmuly, hang in there. You can decide to NOT act out. Remember, school is almost over and you will be moving to Israel and starting a whole new life. Even joining the IDF! Don't let the school's loyalty to the counselor throw you off. You can show them and yourself what a man you are by staying clean. We're rooting for you!
I have become sensitive to individual differences in recovery, and especially here on the forum. This is almost anathema for me as a frum person because
don't we stand for Absolute Truth?! Well, it turns out that in a certain way we really don't. Chassidishe sforim/tzaddikim refer to this as 'al derech avodah', meaning on the practical side of things putting these Ultimate truths
into action requires awareness and acceptance of individual differences.
So along those lines, in hopes of being helpful, here's some annoying, unasked-for, pain-in-the-buttocks feedback:
1- You certainly mean well and sound very encouraging, but: How do you
know that this guy
can decide not to act out? Do you know his history? He has been around here for a long time and been on the GYE merry-go-round many times. Why should anyone be eager to sell him another ticket on just cuz it sounds nice and good to get on the ride? It's very sad for me to see dogma being reloaded onto people who have no grip on certain basic things.
Better help them get the basics...and 'controlling the yetzer hora' is probably way above all the basics he needs. Ratcheting back to the basics is always very uncomfortable for us well-meaning, frum people. Very uncomfortable.
2- Moving and starting a 'new life' is usually the very worst thing for a person with a severe drug habit, drinking habit, porn fantasy and sex (masturbation) habit. The instability of it almost always succeeds in keeping them clean for a while because they are sweeping the dirty plans they have under the rug of life...getting healthy becomes their LAST priority cuz they have so very much to do.
Later the entire under-carpet structure will definitely slip out again in all it's glory and ruin whatever lives they have built for themselves there. This happens over and over and over. I have seen it many times. And one of the weaknesses of GYE is that a person goes through a geographic or other upheaval (like moving, getting married, getting the flu, starting to post on the forum, taking a sh'vuah, experiencing a great Elul, etc.) and lo and behold they post something like, "
Woww! Baruch Hashem yom yom, I have been clean ever since _______ (fill in the magical blank here) happened. I am going to be eternally grateful for this!"
Of course, the problem is that we never
hear from most of these folks a few months later when their old habit returns. Often, they attribute the return of their 'problem' to a new event occurring then...(Mother drove me crazy, new super-pretty girl at work, job not going well, etc, etc) but I believe it is really just the fact that
they never changed that is at work here. They only had what AA's call 'the geographic cure' in the first place. Yet, even though they are only posting with a fake name, they are still too embarrassed to admit it here, so they just disappear or switch usernames. But not to worry! Their 'success testimonial' is forever saved here in electronic media...
3- Joining the IDF can often be the worst thing for a sexually immature and addicted person. The sex going on in the army - perhaps more in the IDF than in some other armies of the western world. It is known that many soldiers refer to females in the IDF as 'mattresses'. It's no joke. It is a tragedy.
Even if he joins a frum unit, things are often made worse because the stress of boot camp and everything else that goes on in that first year is not conducive to religious development or to spiritual centering. Yes, it will likely 'whip a guy into shape'...but if the guy is lacking the tools to integrate it, just wait till he gets out for R&R and watch that baby return with a vengeance.
There is a reason he was banned - and I do not know what it was for I was not involved. But whatever it was, he needs some basics...building blocks that he cannot possibly get by 'reading wisdom on a forum' nor from any sefer. Just like me and most of us, he needs real healthy relationships with the right kind of people that will be therapeutic for him, a good shrink, counselor, etc. None of those things can be gotten with fake names on a virtual forum.
They are just too real and too precious. And he is, too.