In my last post, I promised myself that to keep seder I would write here three times a week. Well… that didn’t happen. But baruch Hashem, life has been moving — with its ups and downs, of course — and recently I’ve been riding a gentle “up.”
This piece is something I actually wanted to write back when I first posted my “Letter to God.” But I couldn’t get myself into that headspace again — too raw, too heavy, too hard to put into words. Only now, with the encouragement (and a little pushing) from the chevra in my weekly vaad, did I finally break through. At first it was messy — lots of false starts, lots of stopping before I could even begin. But once the words finally came, they wouldn’t stop.
What you’re about to read is different. It’s not my words to Hashem… but His words to me.
A reply.
A letter from Hashem to Little Neshamale.
My Precious Little Neshamale,
I read your letter.
Every line. Every tear hidden between the words.
I felt the heaviness in your chest, the anguish that made your hands tremble as you wrote.
You thought you were speaking into the void — but I was right there, gathering every syllable.
You think I only want victories.
You think I am waiting for the day you never slip again,
the day you are clean, strong, holy without blemish.
You think I only rejoice when you resist perfectly,
when your browser stays untouched,
when your body is silent and still.
You think I sit with a ledger,
marking wins and losses,
sighing in disappointment when you fail.
But no, My child. That is not Me.
What I want… is you.
Not the angel you imagine you must become.
Not the dream of perfection you chase.
I want the real you.
The you who stumbles. The you who wrestles. The you who collapses and still whispers My Name.
The you who sat down, raw and trembling, and dared to write Me a letter soaked in pain.
That honesty — that was more precious to Me than a thousand victories.
You feared you drained yourself in that moment. And yes — it cost you.
Because truth always costs.
To rip off the masks, to stand before Me unclothed in spirit — that is no small thing.
But do you know why it drained you so deeply?
Because for the first time, you let yourself feel what you usually bury.
And that pain you felt… was not the end. It was the beginning of healing.
You told Me of your falls, of the cycle that repeats.
I saw the shame as you typed, the anger at yourself, the weariness of “again, again, again.”
And yet, you came to Me.
That, Little Neshamale, is already a victory.
You wrote of freedom — how you dreamed of the day you could do anything you wanted.
And when that day came, you thought it would bring life.
But you’ve learned what few ever do: freedom without seder is not freedom at all.
It is chaos. It is slavery dressed up as choice.
That chiddush you discovered is no accident. I placed it in your heart as a key.
A gift.
Now guard it, use it, live by it.
Yes, I want you to build structure.
Yes, I want you to order your days with wisdom.
Yes, I want you to learn the discipline that will protect you from the Yetzer Hara’s whispers.
But listen closely:
Even if you fail to keep the seder… you are still Mine.
Even when you break your own commitments… I do not break Mine.
I am with you still.
You think I want only strength.
But I also want your weakness.
I want your rushed tefillos, your skipped sedarim, your fragile prayers, your clumsy beginnings.
I want your attempts, your setbacks, your shattered pieces.
Because when you bring Me those, you bring Me the whole you.
And I — I am not tired of you.
Not weary of your davening.
Not sick of your silence in learning.
Not rolling My eyes at your return.
No. I wait, I hope, I ache for you to turn back — and when you do, I run to meet you.
So hear Me now:
Do not measure yourself only in days clean.
Do not define yourself by failures.
Your worth is not in numbers, but in essence.
And your essence is eternal, unbreakable, a flame of My own fire.
So rise again, Little Neshamale.
Fall if you must — but fall into My arms.
Cry if you must — but cry to Me.
Pray even when it feels empty.
Learn even if it’s just a line.
Build your seder, keep your commitments, stumble and stand again.
But never, ever believe you are beyond My love.
For I chose you. And I do not regret My choice.
Not yesterday, not today, not tomorrow.
I am yours. And you are Mine.
Remember, My child: אני לדודי ודודי לי.
I am not waiting at the finish line — I am walking this road beside you.
Forever,
Hashem