Have2changeNOW wrote on 22 Jun 2012 14:45:
Shtark Mussar is good, but like everything else - it wears off. In other words - keep it coming!
I am seeing two schools of thought - external prevention, i.e. a PC filter, or bringing a buddy on a business trip vs truly changing inside, i.e. "the filter in between my ears" to quote Alexeliezer.
For me - the external filter is NECESSARY, but then it does give me some breathing room to work on the internal changes.
its strange - and good for me - that when i have a filter in place, knowing I can't access the p*** seems to cool of the desire/impulsiveness.
According to Dov, and certainly others, for those truly addicted - the best way is to fully take on an SA program, go to the meetings, get a sponsor and WORK IT.
Good Shabbos to all
HAve2Change NOW
Alexeliezer believes in recovery - but the tools of his that you are quoting here refer only to sobriety, not to recovery. Please hear me out for I am not putting anything down here:
Chaza"l argue whether learning Torah is greater than doing mitzvos. They end up saying kind of both: Learning is the ikkar, for it brings one to action (Mitzvos)....so the doing of mitzvos is clearly the goal of the learning - so it is sort of the main thing, but they call learning greater. Funny, but OK.
The Gr"a and others comment on the idea that
ha'omer "ein li ella Torah," af Torah ein lo! Along this same vein.
Now, Torah is certainly da'as Elokim, so attaching ourselves to Hashem by knowing His Da'as is certainly the goal of everything - if Olam habo is neheneh m'biv haShchinah and that is from the Ohr in the Torah, then Torah is obviously the ikkar of it all, period.
But we are not dead yet. Mah yis'onen Odom chai? v'al ta'amin b'atzm'cha ad yom mos'cho...
Bil'am thought he knew Da'as Elyon, too! "Recovery"
is a big word. We all try the best we can to recover and get healthier. But using my own mind to do that is
exactly making the fox in charge of guarding the hen-house. One has to be foolish, self-centered, and in denial (that is, a typical addict like I am) to place his recovery
in his own hands. If there is anyone who needs a double helping of humility, it is the addict in real recovery. Gevalt.
But "Sobriety"
is not as big a word as recovery. We can be in charge of minding our sobriety. After all, who else can? Not G-d. He does a very poor job of it, since He gives bechirah to (nearly) all! No. Only we can guard our eyes, use the filter between the ears, and pray to Him for a daily miracle of protection (from potential trouble) and help (when we feel like getting into trouble anyhow). He is certainly Melech Ozer - uMoshiya.
Like the Chazon Ish (who did not hold of the Mussar derech of Reb Yisroel Salanter, at all) believed, the honest keeping of mitzvos - for the addict that means
sobriety -
automatically leads to
having to become a good man who gets attached to Da'as Elyon - that is
recovery to the addict. Since I
cannot act out - it is not an option I can afford at all (like losing all the money I have R"l). So as I go through life, Life will force my character defects into the spotlight. I
will rage at people, resent people, and will struggle with approval-seeking, lusting, machlokess, fear, and all my other crazinesses. They are part of how I
work...and as long as they are in me, I will not be
able to remain sober very easily. Remaining sober
as I am becomes too uncomfortable - so the work of the 12 steps - or something like it - is
forced upon me. Very Chazon Ish-y. This is not philosophy or "toiroh" - it is experience of many, many addicts (including myself).
So Mussar is nice. Filters are nice. The filter between the ears is indispensable...but
who is in charge of it? Lets not be naive. We need connections with other people in recovery - connections that are real, not virtual. Please do not start to give the mussar and filters too much credence - for on the day that I start to believe that my mussar level is getting powerful enough - I will become doomed to eventually fall on my face and destroy my life with sexual acting out. For I will no longer be dependent on my G-d.
So. Similar to the Chaza"l regarding Torah and/or mitzvos...
The ikkar and tachlis is
Recovery: Sanity and Serenity, ie. getting right with myself, right with my G-d, and right with people.
But the only way to have any chance at all at 'making it', I (as an addict) need
Sobriety - just plain Sobriety - no sex with myself (Masturbation) and no sex with anyone other than my wife. And feeding my lust will make that impossible, so self-honesty is all Iv'e got.
And self-honesty for a professional frum porner and masturbater is a tall order indeed! years of hiding and tricking and faking! So I
only learn how to become honest
with myself, by practicing being honest
with other real people...ala Captain Kirk.