Thanks for sharing all that! I have a few comments.
Firstly, you say
"I have tried to follow GYE's way as I understood it, but it has not worked for me". There is no GYE way. It's an open forum where anyone can post as long as they follow some simple rules of etiquitte. There are many derochim here. It may seem 12 step heavy, probably because that is what is working for
many of us. GYE makes no claim that anyone should use any particular method.
Secondly, the filter issue is relatively minor. It certainly doesn't qualify as something that makes you
"not feel quite comfortable here at GYE". Yes, you need to make gedarim of some sort, but each person on GYE has varying levels and types of gedarim.
Thirdly, I think you do misunderstand the concept of "giving it up to Hashem". I don't quite understand it myself, but it if doesn't work for you, don't use it.
What is more important to understand is that you are a loser (to lust that is). We all are, that's why we're here. Admitting that is difficult, but you seem to have done that - partially. You seem to be still hanging on to the notion that if you just excercise more self-control, you'll be ok. Well, how many years of losing does it take to burst that bubble?
I did the 1st step inventory for the 1st step of the 12 steps a few months ago. The point of it, as I understand is to document your sexual history in A VERY SIMPLE WAY. Just the facts. What did you do, how often, etc. It allows a person to look back and say - I have been losing for years, I am powerless.
Now this seems to be a concept that you are having trouble with. Powerless DOES NOT MEAN I give up and throw in the towel. If it did, it would be kinda pointless - no? The point of it is to see that we have a track record and all of our best efforts haven't worked until now. We need a new derech.
Powerless simply means that we can't
use lust like a non-addict. A non-addict can look at porn and then walk away. It doesn't take him over. An addict
struggles with lust and it consumes him... sooner or later. So we need to move away from the cliff. We have power, not over lust, but to choose to keep FAR away from it. It's still a nisayon, but the battle lines are drawn back.
I think your final lines are the most telilng:
Still, my attitude, tendencies, and worldview have kept me from truly connecting to people on this site and in real life, especially the issue we deal with here. I don't know if I can ever open up enough to do so. I had trouble writing this, fearing rejection, or misunderstanding, or insult, or shame. The same fears that I had about revealing my problem. I decided that honesty is the best policy, especially here, and hope that I have not caused and have not destined myself for any of the above.
I want to keep fighting this fight my way, and I hope that this community can support me in that. Despite the differences and distance that I feel, I love you all and this site as well, and hope that we can help each other in our journeys.
You say it is your
"attitude, tendencies, and worldview" that keep you from opening up to real people, yet a couple lines later you say
"I had trouble writing this, fearing rejection, or misunderstanding, or insult, or shame. The same fears that I had about revealing my problem. I think the latter is probably more true than the former. We all have the same fears. That's why it took us so long to open up. It's only once we realize that we are losers to lust and have no other option - that we take that critical step of reaching out and stop trying to do things
"my way". I lost for 22 years including 12 years married. You are much younger. You have taken steps towards recovery way earlier in life than I did. Are you ready to take the next step?
You can PM me if you want my number. I would be more than happy to talk on the phone.
I hope you did not take any of my words as "rejection, or misunderstanding, or insult, or shame".
We're in this together - brother. Opening up on the phone isn't as hard as you think it is. Just ask your fellow GYErs.
WATLITW,
Gibbor