ToAdd wrote on 17 Aug 2321 17:20:
My own opinion (and I'm no expert in any way) of your situation with the two friends is that if you interfere too much you will be shunned.
You can not change the way one person relates to another.
If your friend asks you for advice on the situation, then your advice will be welcome; but if not, you may stumble across something that hurts him that he's not ready to deal with.
(here I'm actually speaking about a situation I was in and maybe it doesn't apply to your situation, but it's worth thinking about).
I would suggest trying to see what part of your feelings there are based on fact and what part are based on perception. You can ask yourself the following questions:
Are you insecure about losing your friend because of the time he spends with the other guy? This is the very definition of jealousy. Here You need to realize that your relationship with your friend is entirely between you and your friend. If you are a good friend to him, no one else will be able to change that.
How does taking action against the other guy vindicate your friendship for your friend? It may work in movies but I've never seen it in real life.
This first point is actually the underlying dilemma. And by action, I do not mean like in the movies.O0 I was referring to speaking to a Rebbe or someone in a position of authority within the yeshiva to have him removed from either the room (If I did not mention that we are all roommates) or perhaps in a worst case scenario, the Yeshiva.
ToAdd wrote on 09 Feb 2011 08:54:
Perhaps your friend doesn't really mind the way he's being abused?
Some people are outraged by traffic, others see the same traffic as time to listen to a shiur. Some people complain about it just to vent and that helps them deal with it. You most likely feel like reacting because you would not like to be in that situation yourself.
Does it bug you that your friend does not speak up for himself? Is he afraid to?
Is he in danger?
This a very poignant observation, one that I did not really consider until you mentioned it here. I will have to consider this as a real possibility.
Smart and dumb wrote on 10 Feb 2011 01:15:
Second I am sure that your friend asked you for help on this matter, (you should not initiate this type of conversations unless asked)
Yes, he did come over to me. In fact he just plain old complained about it to me for about 5 minutes. The whole time he seemed to be switching between aggravation and justification. So that is why I am in this conundrum. But that is a point that should have been made.
Smart and dumb wrote on 10 Feb 2011 01:15:
P.S. remember your friendship does not depend on how close that person is to your friend rather on how close you are to your friend (maybe your friend needs more then just one friend).
Hope this helps
Thank you again
This is very a very helpful insight. Thanks!!
I truly appreciate the advice, guys. The only reason that I did not respond sooner was because I was actually implementing these ideas in my mind and thinking about how they may play out. I'll let you know of any future developments.