installed wrote on 24 Nov 2010 08:52:
it's funny that you both think that guilt is a bad thing, I thought that it is actually a good thing. [...] I was wishing to feel that remorse that most frum people felt but I didn't.
For what it's worth, my definition of guilt is "regret over failing to fulfill a responsibility that I (myself) took on." So for example, there's no need for guilt if someone from my shul is going home hungry, but there IS appropriate guilt if I had invited that person over and then forgotten! And I'd add one additional factor: I need to be convinced that the guilt is productive toward my improving in that area the next time.
By that standard, why should I have felt "guilty" over years of this stuff? I was convinced it was un-fixable; I was convinced it was better than the other aveiros I'd surely be doing instead; it didn't appear to be hurting other people. I felt as if Hashem made me this way and I was doing the best I can. And better, even. I felt He was probably even happy that I was able to keep everything under control and in check. What was the responsibility that I should have felt?
So therefore, I'm not concerned that I felt no guilt back then. It's only NOW, when I've taken on a RESPONSIBILITY to do better, that I can accept a little (!) guilt when I fail to meet up to that responsibility.
Guilt isn't some Woody Allen, Jewish Mother Joke, Punch Myself Out kind of thing. It's a weapon to use in the next chapter of growth. So my eitza: stop feeling guilty over not feeling guilty in the past. (Your mileage may vary.)