committed_togrowth wrote on 13 Apr 2022 07:17:
Here to type out a few reflections before bed. Another one to skip if you are easily triggered as I'm going to discuss what I think happens to me psychologically when I seek out shmutz. I used to write quite a lot and would use it to explore ideas of what life was about in a pretty deep way. But, when I became a baal teshuva I switched gears pretty much completely to absorbing information and making sure I internalized a correct Torah perspective. I stopped producing ideas of my own, as what I can learn from chazal and my rebbeim is much more valuable than what I can come up with. I do miss engaging with that more creative/philosophical aspect of my mind, it was a defining characteristic of me in the past and I'm going to try to pick it back up. I'm wondering if anyone relates...
I've been wondering lately how much of this struggle actually has to do with sex. It goes without saying that the case will be different for each person. For me, the overwhelming motivation for falling is escape. More accurately it isn't about escape, but instead feeling like I have a place. A place created by the imaginary woman who has always existed in my mind but takes the form of whatever image or real person my fantasy has latched onto in the current moment. A woman who will tend to me, care for me, make her world about me, and give her very own self to me. Somehow the act of this imaginary woman giving herself over to me in the most complete way possible is encapsulated by her revealing her physical body to me as it were. I've wondered for a while why the desire to be nurtured/cared for and sexual desire seem to have their wires crossed (at least for me they do), but I think their connection comes from this phenomenon. Seeing women at a shocking level of intimacy, instantaneously and cheaply creates the sense that they have given themselves over to you as a token to keep. And, what I imagine to be a willing, loving, self-imposed objectification by this imaginary woman for me and to satisfy my whims creates a deep feeling of being taken care of. Of course it is me doing the objectification and this exists purely in the realm of my imagination.
This I believe is the psychological pull that drives me to look at shmutz. It is the desire to fall into another human being who exists solely for me. This explains why my most triggered moments are those where I feel like a failure, unwanted, insecure etc. Anyway, just some thoughts I've been mulling over.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I bolded one line above. I just want to say that the biggest irony about this feeling that you (and probably so many millions of others) feel is that
these women are literally the farthest you could possibly get from being solely for you. They are literally the most disgusting, hefker women in the world that put themselves naked in front of hundreds of millions of men. This realization is something that definitely helps me to be disgusted by pornography, which is agav an extremely powerful tool for quitting (i.e., to be disgusted by it). If similar feelings hit you in the future, you could try to think about how literally
not solely for you these disgusting animals are and maybe it will help to evaporate the lies.
Keep on growing and sharing! I enjoy reading your posts!