So sorry about the long megillah here, but I suggest you read some, then take a nap, wash neigel-vasser, read some more...maybe finish it in a few sittings....ha-ha-ha. Laag vokeless! And you said that u-r-ajew is depressing
you? What a username, gevalt!
Anyway, after reading your thread, I am impressed at your
tfisah of some of the problem:
other ppl are capable to control it, but me?no i cant control it
and
And i dont get how is that posible to control my lust when i already saw what i saw...
, etc.
These diamonds are things I have tried to knock into some chronic floppers' heads for a long, long time. And here you come already wrapped up in the package mit aleh pechechkelach! (is that really a word?)
I am serious. You are a very lucky man, chaver. (It is also nice to see that someone else besides me laughs his head off when the bardichever writes his geshmakeh stuff).
Now, tachlis - what to
do about it?
You do not seem to get insulted easily, so here I go:
It's funny to me. First you say it's completely hopeless b'derech Hateva, and Hashem y'rachem.
Then when a guy who is actually getting better answers that you are
right - that we
are sick in the head and do
not have the power to get out of this trap - you argue that it can't be!
Whose side are you on? :D
You say, "Hakitzer: some one that fell 11000000 times THIS CANT HELP, but its good cause every second u r here and not there its already a oifti" - but you do know that there are many people, including many frummeh yidden who learn as much as you (I bet) and have done
much worse than you ever did (I bet), for longer than you have (I bet), and lied even more than you have (I bet),
and yet are sober and living a different life than before. (maybe I have a betting problem! ;D)
I spend one or two shabbosos almost every year with about two hundred frum yidden and yeshivah avreichimn/yungerleit who are porn and sex addicts (we call ourselves "Lust addicts") and are working to be free of this in recovery. Many are, b"H free for
years. They say they are
still addicts,
still unable to win the fight, but still
clean - for years. And they are not suffering and not in the torture that you describe so well.
And many come for that Shabbos with their wives, too. Twice every year, besides the meetings they go to a few times every week together with other sex/schmutz and lust addicts. I have been going for almost 14 years. Am I stupid? No, cuz it's free! ;D
There are over a thousand frummies who regularly go to these meetings in Yerushalayim, Beit Shemesh, Tel Aviv, Be'er Sheva, (lehavdil) BP, Monsey, Baltimore, etc...
You can't have it both ways. If you can kvetch that you "are k'var metumtam with this schmutz and can't get out!" then you can give up the fight and learn how to let Hashem help you. Are you ready to sit at the feet of other addicts (who may be frum yidden, frayeh yiddin, rabbonim, prusteh goyim, or whatever) who are sober, to learn how to be just plain clean? They can teach you how to be what comes
before even being a frummeh yid: Derech Eretz.
I do not believe it is honest to say "it is my YH that is making me do it, eve though I am a nice guy and have good sechel." No way. Normal people do not do this habitual garbage, kvetch about how much they hate that they do it and how terrible it is, then do it even more....that's weird - like me!
So please stop passl'ing/judging anybody else's eitzos in this stuff - if
they are clean, just
listen, for a change. Your sechel is what got you all tied up in this meshugeneh knot to begin with. Your best wisdom - is
your biggest problem!
This business of "depending on Hashem" for help in this disgusting and stupid problem we have, is
not something you will learn from your sechel. Your sechel is already full of shtuyot. It's time to think a lot
less and do a lot
more.
As far as
entertainment is concerned, I have found that I can get very busy talking with other sickos and perverts like me who are interested in the same recovery that I have been given. We get together at a few meetings every week, talk a few times a day on the phone, and I write my chazerai here on the forum and in emails...it's great fun, very entertaining.
So I suggest trying this recovery thing and seeing how busy and full your life gets. 'Suddenly". It's kind of funny...but true. If you need enough entertainment that you end up watching porn for it, then you may not be happy enough and busy enough with your life.
Just my opinion. Nothing personal.
You don't have time for all that? It sounds like it's no fun at all, and just hard work? You have atzlus. So do I. Nu, it might be hard in the beginning. But all that changes.
Once you see there is a better way to live, it changes. The
guf sees it. In the beginning few days or weeks the guf goes crazy - it misses the schmutz and the isolation and the pleasure of being irresponsible.
But after a while, with Hashem's assistance and the help of other addicts who understand, even the guf starts to feel the relief, the calm, not needing to feed my
brenn - the 'emergency' to see another little shtickle porn video tonight...I just don't need it! It is like Shabbos menucha compared to the nutty, stressful week. Sobriety is menuchah.
It really
is a neis. I, who lived from porn to porn...now I actually have better things to do! I can
live. I am busy doing things like kissing my children, walking with my wife (or even by myself), chasing the kinderlach around the house and playing hide-and-seek, reading them to bed, washing the dishes (or shmoozing with my wife while
she washes them :
)...building something for the house or for my wife's zaidy's house...whatever.
All this took a some time - some changes took a few days, some a few weeks, some a few months, and some took a few years. And I see that I am still with problems but getting better, b"H. Schmutz and selfishness do not rule my life any more, b"H.
To me, you are just a smart man who has discovered that he cannot talk to his
guf. My
guf doesn't speak any language except pleasure, and pain. You cannot
'talk' to a guf. My guf wants lust, it wants porn, zera levatolah, and sex. It just
wants - Hav-hav.
But I do not need to feed it, and it will not die. If not for recovery, I would
have to feed it, no shayloh. And it would make me meshugah and ruin my life.
But HKb"H has shown me (slowly, through recovery in the 12 step program) that there are 'two dinnim' here (are you a brisker?):
1- my guf just desiring the high of searching for the best video images, excitement and sex with myself (zera levatolah);
and
2- what is
behind the schmutz mishegaas: that sweet warm loving feeling that nothing else gives me - the schmutz really understands me and gives me what I really need!
With my chevra of other mishugo'im like me, Hashem has helped me to start getting all that sweetness from my personal relationship of love with Him, from my relationships with my friends, and from the relationship my wife and I have, and from my life - without depending on schmutz like a slave any more. For you are describing our slavery, you know.
Was any of that helpful to you? Are we friends?
PS. I hear in your words that "Once we have seen this, we can't be good any more". This is silly. To see yourself as not "good" any more? I feel in your words that in your mind you might believe that Hashem cannot be in love with you any more, now that you have this terrible p'niyoh from seeing the schmutz.
I can say what Reb Tzvi-Meyer shlit"a (and any tzaddik) would say, "chas veSholom! Don't believe it!...blah, blah..." but I won't. I'll say this instead: such a belief is just an excuse for us to be able
to keep doing it without so much guilt and shame. It is a lie and just plain silly. Hashem is so much bigger than our aveiros and shtuyot that His Ahavah for us overshadows anything we could possibly do wrong. He is waiting for us to be with Him - deveikus with Him - and giving to us so much all the time no matter what. And when we start doing the stuff that will really help us get better and closer to Him
one day at a time -
Hayom al levovecha - He will help us. We just need to learn how not to kick away His help. That's recovery, to me. I don't call it teshuvah...just recovery. But maybe the word "recovery" is really the teitch of teshuvah....whatever. That's His business. My concern is staying clean and living right.
He takes care of all the rest.