I will address al rishon rishon, though not with the same arichus. I’ve been trained to get to the point.

Marriage. I hope by dating I’ll  see if we are compatible. Of course marriage takes work and there are no guarantees. Nothing is guaranteeed in life. 

shmiras habris. Having read the threads, it is clear thst the act is much more than a replacement for MB. But when performed with the proper intent, there should be no need to MB. 

pas besalo there are no guarantees. Clearly lust is a lifelong challenge. But one of the suggested ways for dealing with it is marriage 

loneliness I will concede that marriage does not in and of itself guarantee a remedy. But in the context of a healthy marriage, this is usually provided. We all hope for a healthy marriage. 


Bayis. Again nothing is guaranteed. We hope for the best. And with proper guidance the probability is there. Siata dish maya is necessary, but no reason to delay shiduchim 

Perfection. This is a lifetime pursuit. No reason to delay marriage for this reason. 

In sum, inyaney kedusha are something that we have to work on as early as the teen years, going forward. But this is a lifetime project. Marriage with proper preparation is the best unit within which to engage in this. It is counter productive to delay getting married until you’ve mastered the myriad of issues that have to be addressed.

So after having reviewed what’s been written about it on this forum and having given it consideration and reflection, I was just adding my 2 sense to the mix. 

I’d be intrigued to read responds from jewizard21 and others. Life is a learning process and my opinion may change. 

    Even when you find the right person you will have differences and conflicts. Things that seem small to you can be big issues to her, decisions made without including the other because "I thought you wouldn't mind/would say yes" and other types of things can cause bumps in the road and maybe worse of not dealt with pr adapted to.

    Even with the proper intent on what sex in marriage really is, which I doubt you or I truly will understand till we are married but till then can only speculate and hope to have a proper choson teacher, there is still lust. There are many factors involved and it's not as simple as "I am now having sex so I don't need masturbation". What happens if you get an urge and she is a Nida/after child birth or even just not in the mood, you may be tempted to just get it over with and masturbate . Again having her in mind and being considerate to her is vital to a healthy relationship.

    If people are suggesting to you that marriage is a way to "deal" with it then they are wrong.

    What do you mean that there's no reason to delay shidduchim? With regards to binyan habayis if you are not financially and mentally prepared then it could be detrimental to you and your family. Again siyata dishmaya does not replace hishtadlus, if you are gonna learn and have someone support you then your hishtadlus is to learn. Others have other circumstances.

    This is case by case but it is not always way counter productive to delay shidduchim/marriage. Me for instance, I don't have parnasa or others to provide parnasa, schooling is extremely time constraining (this is a really difficult degree) I feel it would be wrong to start a relationship with someone when I can't even give them a the time of day.
    I hope you can tell by the way I've thought about these topics that one of the things I want most in life right now is to get married. But a very important thing to remember is that marriage is not about the "me" it's about the us, and right now, no matter how much I want to, I am not prepared for the "us". We have to remember that Hashem has a plan for all of us.

    Life is a journey, and on this journey there are many hardships. Overcoming this nisoyon is not a instant win nor a final win, it is a fight that we Must take One Day At A Time. Life is one day at a time, and the only way to be prepared for the future or to better/maintain ourselves is to tale today and do the best to be the person we want to become. We can't wait till any set date to figure stuff out because who knows what the future holds, we only control the present, and in the present we obtain perfection in the future.


Keep on Trucking, One Day At A Time!!

livingagain wrote on 24 Jan 2025 01:04:

If someone can have proper intimacy maybe that can help them stop masturbating (and maybe not). But what if masturbating prevents them from having proper intimacy? What about when she's a nidah for 2 weeks, or a couple of months after childbirth? Intimacy isn't just much more than masturbating, it's not the same thing at all. 


Sorry that I'm repeating myself, but marital intimacy is not lust. If you bring that lust into your bedroom, then it will still be lust, which will hinder intimacy. It will also likely show up elsewhere. A marriage that starts with sex as an answer to lust puts its foundations in taking, which makes it a poor Plan A. The internal work and the lust need to be addressed before pas besalo enters the scene. 


I'm still hearing a mixed message. You need to prepare for marriage, and this is part of the preparation. Maybe not a full stop, but to say waiting is counterproductive again sounds like you feel you have a better chance of dealing with inyanei kedusha issues after marriage, which is not necessarily true and also disincentivizing to put in the proper work now. 


My Brother, it is not my intention to sound hard, but I think it's important to be clear, so we can understand where each other is coming from. 
Kol Tov

Hi livingagain and chevra

Just to reiterate a couple of the points which were already said which resonate the most with me 

The yh for arayos is something literally every (healthy) man has to contend with. And when that healthy person gets married, and forms a bond with his wife through much hard work, he will probably find that his struggle has gotten much easier.

But when a person is struggling with this yh in a way which goes beyond what's normal for a 'healthy' person, then the same things inside which are causing him to struggle are almost guaranteed to prevent him from having that marriage which he wants, which would have made his struggle easier.
What's more - these same issues may cause the marriage itself to be a very very painful experience which not only doesn't help but becomes a catalyst for acting out.

(Anecdotally, before I got married my Rebbi told me that in marriage I will experience emotions which are more painful than anything I'd experienced before. And this was after a childhood which included very real trauma. And a Rebbi who is a very emotionally healthy person. And he was right.) 

So bottom line - if the issues go beyond 'healthy male', they must be dealt with. Dealing with them before getting married is a very good idea for multiple reasons. If a person succeeds in dealing with those issues before getting married, and success is a sliding scale, we have to work our whole lives to improve, then they will find that now they're a normal healthy male, which includes a real degree of struggle. But that struggle will likely be helped with marriage, provided that the marriage is worked on a lot.