kilochalu wrote:
I am so confused. Ploni wrote about 'winning that day (and knowing that the battle rages on)', how does that sound like thinking that we can be 'rid of the problem'. Is there a real disagreement here or is it just a matter of semantics, or (and I think this is the truth) Chesky gets chizuk from reiterating again and again and again that we cannot win on our own w/o Hashem's help.
Both are true.
For some people, this is a battle they can win on their own, and with the right push, chizzuk and tools they can win.
For me nothing worked long term. I do not get chizzuk from reiterating that I am powerless. I just acknowledge that that is the reality (even though I may feel otherwise), and therefore I turn to HaShem to help me, and thankfully He does one day at a time.
plonialmoni11 wrote:
I'ts different then cancer or diabeties or debt, bc with those its just there, and nothing they do makes a difference but if I was an alcoholic or SA or MZLA (motzie zera levatal anonymous) I must fight to stay sober each day! If I give up for a second I drown in the shmutz. With Cancer it just is and there is only a battle to survive or to be happy, but there is none of that "dont go there" "close your eyes or else" dont take that first sip".. etc..
For me there is no difference. I believe (based on my track record) that there is NOTHING I can do on my own to stay sober.
For me the reason I do not take the first drink is not because that is what will keep me sober,
but because I cannot afford to. I have to admit powerlessness over that first drink; otherwise I will not remain sober.
However avoiding that first drink will not keep me sober on its own. Even if I avoid all triggers etc, I still have a problem and that is, that my head still convinces me that lust is the best thing for me and that it can solve all my problems. I am convinced that if I do not have my drug then I will not be able to function or to remain sane. And there is NOTHING for me to do about that on my own. My mind and my body both send me messages that without their drug, they will cease to function.
And at that point I am the same as the guy who is sick, or in debt, in that I am powerless over my situation.
But thankfully I learnt that as powerless as I am, I am not hopeless. I have come to believe that HaShem, my loving Abba, cares for me and can restore my sanity even if I do not act out, just as he can help the sick guy or the guy in debt.