Welcome, Guest

Daf Yomi Questions and Answers
(0 viewing) 
Im Paga be’cha menuval zeh, mushchei'hu le- BEIS HAMEDRASH! This board is for divrei Torah relating to our struggle with the Yetzer Hara, from the entire spectrum of Tanach, Chazal, Mussar and Chassidus. On this board there will be no posts about personal struggles and no debates. Only TORAH CHIZUK.

TOPIC: Daf Yomi Questions and Answers 5007 Views

Re: Daf Yomi Questions and Answers 21 Aug 2012 15:37 #144001

  • ur-a-jew
  • Current streak: 1087 days
  • OFFLINE
  • Platinum Boarder
  • Posts: 1717
  • Karma: 55
ברכות דף ט"ז

The mishna teaches us that a chosson is pottur from Krias Shema and then tells us that ומעשה בר"ג שנשא אשה וקרא לילה הראשונה אמרו לו תלמידיו למדתנו רבינו שחתן פטור מק"ש.

1. Didn't the talmidim know the next Mishna which states חתן אם רוצה לקרות קרית שמע לילה הראשון קורא?
2. How come Rabbi Gamliel didn't respond with that mishna?
3. How come Rebbi when he was misader the Mishna separated חתן אם רוצה לקרות קרית שמע לילה הראשון קורא רבן שמעון בן גמליאל אומר לא כל הרוצה ליטול את השם יטול from the earlier discussion of a chosson?
Help free Sholom Rubashkin by giving him the zechus of Shemiras Eiynayim.  www.guardyoureyes.org/forum/index.php?topic=2809.0

Re: Daf Yomi Questions and Answers 24 Aug 2012 00:15 #144122

  • E-Tek
  • Current streak: 25 days
  • OFFLINE
  • Gold Boarder
  • Posts: 317
  • Karma: 1
ur-a-jew wrote on 16 Aug 2012 19:20:

ברכות דף י"ד

The gemara asks whether someone who is fasting can taste אכילה ושתיה קביל עליה והא ליכא או דילמא הנאה קביל עליה והא איכא. From the gemara's question it seems that tasting is not considered eating but it would be considered הנאה. The gemara answers טועם ואין בכך כלום which suggests that the gemara concludes that tasting is not considered eating but that is all that is prohibited. Tosafos seems to have a different understanding however since Tosafos says that the reason that you can taste is שחוזר ופולט דלא חשיב הנאה מן הטעימה אבל בולע לא. In other words, according to Tosafos הנאה is what is forbidden but this is not הנאה.

1. Where does Tosafos see this in the gemara?

2. How does Tosafos understand the follow-up question of the gemara עד כמה טעמי, since in any event, one is not swallowing it, what difference does it make how much you put in your mouth?

Just saying, while not necessarily related to the question, the sugya of tasting in Halacha can be located in the beginning of יו"ד סי' צ"ח, in סע' א. There is a discussion on what kind of tasting is muttar by treif and on fast days, involving using your tongue, or putting in your mouth, etc.
I don't remember if the discussion will answer your stira or not. I need to do chazara.
Time to create page: 0.32 seconds

Are you sure?

Yes