simchastorah wrote on 26 Jan 2025 21:43:
chaimoigen wrote on 26 Jan 2025 18:07:
Recognizing an urge and posting about it here, with details, takes Gevura and courage.
And externalizing the urge is usually helpful.
This is an impressive accomplishment.
Don’t focus only on the levels you have yet to achieve without also focusing on where you thankfully are. You’ve accomplished a lot. You’re an impressive person, and you should give yourself credit and compassion.
Today will be another day of Tahara, building the Oved Hashem that you are further.
Youll keep striving and Shteiging.
Hang on. Here’s a warm hand, from an admiring friend.
Chaim Oigen.
Thanks for the kind words.
I was going to raise a bit of a question about the bolded bit, but after rereading I understood it differently, and I think more correctly. You are not saying that one should not evaluate whether his behavior is correct and seek to fix that which is not correct. You're saying that that should be done, but done together with an appreciation of the larger process that one is traversing and the accomplishments which have already been achieved.
If I had to explain why I think that that's a good idea I'd give two reasons.
1) Self criticism can be dangerous. The danger is that I will come to see myself in a negative light. The danger of seeing myself in a negative light is that it a) leads to depression, which spirals into all sorts of bad things and b) causes me to see myself as one for whom the bad behavior is in fact befitting, chipping away at my motivation to stay strong in where I am and all the more so to continue to strive
2) Like the msilas yesharim says, there are two components to the cheshbon hanefesh done regarding behavior and שלא בשעת מעשה. a) recognizing what needs to go, and b) recognizing what must be kept.
But knowing our friend and teacher chaimoigen he has more to add, or a different way to say it, and I'd love to hear it.
I appreciate your kind words, they mean a lot to me.
I agree wholeheartedly with your presentation of the point I was making, and with your explanation of the reasons why not listening to my point would be a bad idea.
I would just add an “Aseh Tov” aspect, on top of the “Sur Merah” reasons you’ve articulated so well.
A Yid has seeds of greatness inside. You certainly do. Not just deep thoughts and realizations. But also Torah outlooks, Hashkafa and goals. And tremendous Sheifos that are sourced in the bottomless wellspring of a Neshoma Elyona.
You (and everyone one else, certainly including me) also is challenged by parts of a personality that are currently challenged by Katnus Hamochin and חומריות. These, lower aspects of our personality cause conflict and seek to weigh us down, and cause to get stuck and hung up on small or negative things from time to time.
When the ‘greater’ part of a person is struggling with the ‘petty’ part, it’s important to see and identify with the greatness. Even the greatness that’s still potential.
Here are two ways to think about overcoming an urge and not falling:
“I’m a work in progress, building greatness, getting there step by step. Not all the way there but on my way. I know what my next step is.”
That way of thinking about yourself helps
build that goal and it helps unlock those seeds in your Neshoma.
“I’m a potentially pathetic failure who just barely managed to avoid falling, at least, but shouldn’t have been there in the first place”
That is a message that won’t help unlock those potential seeds of Gadlus.
Viewing yourself with compassion and positivity doesn’t mean whitewashing over the work that still needs to be done. It means giving approval and appreciation to the special guy who IS doing the work, and recognizing that he is worth caring about, liking, and investing in.
I think this talks to your follow-up post as well. If you’re busy being
harsh on yourself, you may never feel that you’ve done enough, and push yourself too fast too far, with
dissatisfaction, and that doesn’t look pretty.
If, however, you can appreciate and approve of yourself where you are today, (while still knowing where you need to get to), you can be comfortable about progressing further, step by step, without dissatisfaction. That leads to more healthy and lasting growth, I think.
באהבה והוקרה,
אוהב ימים
לראות טוב