Tried-123 wrote on 18 Mar 2010 23:03:
dov wrote on 18 Mar 2010 13:43:
C'mon.
I'd like to start a thread called: "Do people with an attractive (really, really nice) G-d have less emunah problems?"
These are all absolutely true, and all totally selfish concerns.
I know what they are because I have them all.
The way I'd put the question here is:
"Is it realistic for me to ever find total satisfaction without total sexual gratification in my wife? You say your hormonal juices are 'irrelevant' - I say you are a baldface liar. We all are and will always be selfish, period." And it's a fair question, to me.
But the real problem we have isn't our wives, it is the screaming lunatic inside us that will never, ever be bothered by the question: "Is it realistic for my wife to ever find total satisfaction with a self-centered (but very natural!) guy like me?" And that is often our undoing - it unravels the love our wives are ready to give us and makes them much uglier to us. We hold the key to their love - and it isn't our 'eivers', much as we like to dream that it'd do it for them....
I think I need another Dov-Translation.... (Dov you do it best -Howbout just a one or two sentence Chazoras Hashiur....)
First: Lets call a spade a spade: If there would not be a whole list of severe punishments for sins then I WOULD HAVE AN ABSOLUTELY EASIER TIME relating to the concept of a loving G-d.
So to answer your question: "Do people with an attractive (
really, really nice) G-d have less emunah problems?"
YES ABSOLUTELY I can't really comment on the rest of your post since I didn't fully get it...
Sorry I express myself poorly at times...ok, often....at least I do check for spelling errors sommetines...ok, one in a whiel. ha. oy vei.
OK, I hear you, and your true words above have been passing through my squishy mind every now and then over the past couple of days.
My main points were these: While it is true that it is natural for many of us to have emunah problems when we feel Hashem is not doing things our way, by the same token, we tend to be unfaithful (in some respect) and disrespectful to our wives when we don't get what we expect out of them.
This whole thing is part of the question the Gr"a asks: If we were not "good" in eretz yisroel
with a beis hamikdash and
with neviim, then how in the world are we to
ever get better
out of eretz yisroel and
w/o any neviim?! A good question, no?
(It's reminiscent of teshuva
having to be by way of the top opening of the letter "Hay" that the world is compared to in the gemorah in menachos, if you are familiar with that shtik'l, but I digress.)
His answer is that there is just no other way to get better when we screw up (my phrase), except by attaching ourselves to a higher level or deeper relationship with Hashem than we had before we went wrong. And the only way to do that is by reaching out of where we really are, spiritually. Staying in ET with a Beis haMikdosh and neviim, would only make us think we are
higher than we really are, and that we need Hashem
less than we really do! In the very same way, Odom needed to get sent
out of the Gan - he
was lower and had to reach for Hashem from
there.
Reality is what we need! There ain't no easy way out, as the song goes. We need to be made to face ourselves, somehow, eventually. At least, that's how I understand his answer. And that's how I understand the 1st step experience, too. (I can't remember where it's written in Gaon, maybe someone else here does. If I botched it all up, please forgive me.)
We are a mess. We are basically blind, and have puny brains - a shadow of the real Da'as that is His/Him. Lust overtakes us, as do our fears, pride, and resentments. No blame there - it's just the way it is for many of us. We rarely see farther than our own wishes and 'rights' and even the perspective of another
human usually eludes us, let alone that of the Divine. We rarely even care, really...that's what it means to be the average human being. Nu. And he loves us.
I think many of us (me especially) need
hachno'oh (a broken heart/broken ga'avoh) more than anything else, for recovery. And through sobriety and recovery with hachno'oh, our relationships with our G-d and with fellow man (and spouses) will become right-sized. Then they will actually begin to
work for us. The emunah will begin to actually function the way it is meant to, and the relationships will actually grow and be fun!
Does that make any sense to you tried-123?