eyes wrote on 16 Aug 2021 03:24:
Hi Everyone,
BH had a pretty good day.
I took my family to a park with a splash pad. (it has running water with fountains in a park, and people come dressed for swimming and dance around on the pad) BH I was able to look and BH that was really good.
But at the end of the day was a bit hard not with shmiras einayim thou.
I want to put it out there. I know this may be a thing for the BB forum, but I really want to know what the bochurim have to say as well.
I have a sister in law that is older than me by a few months. I am BH 32. She is not yet married. There is a guy who has been bugging me for over a year to set up a date for him. I always said that I am not involved and that he should go directly to my father in law the girls father. So he is about 14 years older than her (turning 47) went to my father in law and asked him to date his daughter. My father in law told him "I am not involved in her shidduchim", which he really is. Now this guy has never been married and he really does. Unfortunately he has other issues as well. So because he was told by the girls own father that he is not in charge of her shidduchim, so the man called me and called other cousins to my wife and tried to get them to match him up. Everyone knowing him pushed him off and said that they are not getting involved. But this guy wont relent, so he called one of the senior cousin and asked him to set up a date. So this senior cousin told this guy that he should speak to his father. His father the uncle of my wife and sister in law is a prominant rov and posek, who is highly sought after.
Today this guy who wants to date my sister in law calls me up and said that the senior cousin said to call his father and this guy asked me to call on his behalf.
I knew that my wife would not be supportive of this phone call. But if you realize through the whole story, that nobody wants to set him up. But he doesnt get the point, because nobody is saying a flat no, including the girls own father.
So I decided that I need to put an end to this story. As my sister in law is running through this guys head 24/7 and he thinks he still has a chance because nobody has told him no.
So tonight I picked up the phone and called my wife's uncle to tell him that his own son (the senior cousin) said that it should go to his father. So the uncle a very smart man took the reins and helped me stop this whole parsha by telling this guy the following. "I gave it over to the uncle and if they think it is something to pursue then they will get back to you." the conversation was done.
My wife heard the whole conversation and she extrapolated that I think that it is a good shidduch. For over an hour I had to convince her that I didnt think so, and I just needed to stop this whole thing and help this guy realize that it is time to move on. She thinks and as much as I tried to explain it to her that everyone has been pushing this guy off and not telling him to stop. Everyone is giving him false hopes that there still may be a chance of him marrying her.
I am hurt and insulted that my wife is not giving me the benifit of the doubt and weighing me on the kaf zechus that I am really trying to help this guy and her sister move on But she doesnt see what I am trying to say.
In any case what would you do?
If you knew someone may have psychological issue, are you going to ruin a possible shidduch?
ANy rabbonim on this site?
Thanks for your input
EYES
It really depends what type of psychological issues.
If the guy is on meds for like depression and he’s stable then I’d say no problem. I know many quality guys here in Yeshiva who are on meds for anxiety/depression and are completely stable and normal.
Other more intense stuff which aren’t controlled is a whole dif shaila.