Briut wrote on 09 Jun 2010 02:59:
You know, the guys who hate themselves for what they want. Who hate themselves for foresaking the Torah or even thinking about it... and Hashem hates both them AND what they do, etc.
YA: There are distinctions that are a little hard to define. In my view, as soon as we start to say "hate the sin, love the sinner," we've already poisoned the well. For me, I don't see my own "sins" (of any nature) as a poison within me, I see them as PART of the whole package that is me. I don't have to "hate" them in order to love myself enough to work on them.
I'm afraid that lotsa folks who go around spouting Torah reasons to stop doing sin a, b, c are really just talking to themselves, and are really just telling themselves how hated, hate-able, and irredeemable they are. Which means that Hashem would have to hate them, too, or else He'd be, so to speak, an idiot (Ch'v).
Folks might be better off if they simply stood up, declared their "sin," took all the wind out of its sails, and just went back to work. [Maybe I'm starting to sound like the 12-step model, after all. (Go figure!)] But I can't see how we can breathe hellfire and brimstone against a sin that we hold, without coming to hate ourselves.
I know I'm rambling. Am I even CLOSE to understandable yet?