Pintele Yid wrote on 25 Aug 2009 21:47:
kutan shel hachabura wrote on 25 Aug 2009 03:35:
Helige Pintele,
That said, I'd like to pick up on something that Yechida hinted at, from his vantage point in the pristine wilderness... that is, that this idea of seeing signs from Heaven is a dangerous thing. I know R' Pam was against it, and I know R' Tatz quotes R' Eliyashuv as saying we can not today's days judge from events a specific lesson. This is for schar v'onesh, which in days begone was clearly meant to be used to figure out where we went right or wrong.
Kol Sheckain here, where we are dealing with 'cute' things, it is dangerous to decide that since we are in some sort of 'deal' with HKBH and since we are doing our part, He is going out of His way to show us that He is with us.
At the most, we should simply thank him humbly for the kindness that he shows us, even in these mundane humdrum matters such as coming exactly on time, or reaching home at the very moment it rains. These do not hold a candle to the myriad of mofsim he does with us constantly in our body's functions, in our asek haparnasa, in our gidul banim, etc etc but they are as you say important anyway, just as the Gemara calls taking out the wrong coin 'yesurim', since, as R' A. Miller would explain, by the very fact you realize it is min hashamayim, you elevate it to importance and you can use it as needed yesurim.
Sincerely,
Kutan
k
Heiliga Kutan (Ari) and to others who might have knowledge in this area,
I am using these events as a Chizuk for me that my personal Tefilos have an immediate impact. I am therefore very motivated to continue. Were Rav Pam and R' Eliyashuv against that?
I guess that possibly Hashem knows that I am maybe not strong enough to continue these personal Tefilos in the long term, if I don't see at least
some short term results. So he is giving me chizuk that normally doesn't happen - who knows?
I am now very confused.
Did they ever discuss the Tefilo of Eliezer that right way produced a result? Was only
he zocha to such S'yata Dishmaya and we shouldn't expect it? Permit me to ask a rhetorical quesion. Is the Torah a storybook Chas Vesholom of lives of Tzaddikim/Reshaim or something that we can apply to our daily lives?
One confused Pintele Yid :-\
Dear confused,
Your question is a good one. Maybe better than my answer. But as I understand it, our generation has fallen so low in the hishtalshulis, that we have only hester panim today.
We still have a chiuv to be mefashpaish b'masov, but only in a general way. No "midah k'neged mida" type of thing.
BTW, as an aside, there is a huge machlokes if Eliezer was allowed to rely on a siman that his tefila was accepted. It may have in fact been assur, part of the issur of making signs for oneself, and the p'shat is simply that a woman who excels in chessed is by essence the right zivug for Yitzchok. It was a siba, not a siman. You ask what is wrong in doing this in a positive way...
When Shabtai Tzvi was on a roll, he was causing a massive teshuva movement in Europe and some Rabonim felt the same way, they believed it would be worth it to use him as a tool, even if it was not real. But the danger in doing that is clear, as history showed.
We need to find Hashem in our lives the way the yiddin did in Megilas Ester = Hester. Mordichai went right back to his sack and taanis, even after the amazing events of Haman's leading him around Shushan, and getting his daughters garbage on his head, etc.
This type of closeness to Hashem is actually stronger. As the Chasideshe story goes, believing that the ushpizin are there in the Sucah is greater than actually seeing them.
All this said, I need to report back to you that today again I remembered two times to daven for something. At least I'm not sliding backwards. Hope to continue, in your z'chus.
Kutan