simchastorah wrote on 09 Dec 2024 17:16:
For me this is similar. Sure everyone has a yetzer hara. And I have no problem talking about it in an abstract way, and truthfully even in a concrete way when I'm talking about something in the past, because that's just 'past me'. But when right now I feel a desire to do a shameful thing, speaking about it is saying "hey i have this aspect of me which is really quite shameful!". And that's embarrassing.
Fantastic post and discussion.
Two points.
1) If it was just talking to schmooze about the
urge, then you would have an extremely valid point. But the point is that calling someone to share that your having an
urge is an extremely powerful method of killing that urge. I think this is HHM's advice. Just calling someone and sharing is a powerful tool. And a part of the power of that tool I think is the sense of shame. Simply saying it out loud helps you realize how bad of an idea it is. So if you can, recognize that even though it's embarrassing it's also very helpful for you to do it and put on your (unsoiled) big boy pants and do it.
2) Without getting into whether or not you should feel embarrassment about this, the fact is that you do. But calling someone to share doesn't mean getting into every gory detail. It means the general picture. To continue with the incontinence mashal - you're not calling and sharing how you lost control and feces got everywhere and there were little flecks of corn leftover in there from the bbq last night and now your couch has a stain on it shaped like Australia that smells like rotten corn. That would indeed be embarrassing. You're sharing more the trigger that is making you
want to act out, not the details of
how you want to act out.
E.g., I'm feeling frustrated so I want to pretend like I'm going on Youtube to check the news and end up spending an hour on inappropriate content. Not getting into detail about the exact shape and flavor of the inappropriate content.
This is, I think, less embarrassing.
3) A bonus point. To echo CO's point about the Bastille of shame. It's totally normal to be ashamed and not want to reach out. This is something that keeps us trapped in acting out. We are effectively telling ourselves something like: "Oh, I'm so disgusting, so ashamed of my terrible life. I can't possible talk about this. The only thing I can do is to keep on acting out (since the ways to get out of acting out are so embarrassing.)" This is a very harmful thing.
That being said, you can ease into reaching out. Posting is a good start. Then perhaps find one person whose posts resonate with you and reach out to them. One of the big guys maybe, who speak to dozens of people and if their contact list gets out half the Jewish world is going down with you. Then maybe make a friend or two. No rush, and no mitzva to speak to everyone. But opening up takes a hammer to the gates of shame, and it feels pretty darn good to be on the other side of that gate. This paragraph is literally just a summary of my personal experience.
Hatzlacha!
Side point: I disagree with looking at the
urge as a thought from someone who is "not me". It's helpful as a short term technique to avoid a given
urge, e.g.
urge surfing or find the fox techniques. But in the long term, you'll probably find that it is indeed you who wants these things, and that's why you do them. Not "society," not "the internet," not "the yetzer hara," but
you.
And when you start realizing that you do want this, you can deal with resolving that want in a better way. But if you always disassociate yourself from the
urge then you will never resolve those inner drives and they may pop up again in the most unexpected and unhelpful places.
is often not "me" at all. hashem gave us a natural reaction to certain stimuli which does not at all represent what we want.
with regards to the feelings of desire that we associate with our physical or emotional drive, see chapter 16 of The Battle of the Generation. being able to identify and separate the feelings that are not coming from our intellect can be a very powerful tool.
When i first started my recovery i truly believed that these feelings were a part of me and that people who told me "that's not really you" just didn't know me. With time i came to realize that they were absolutely correct and that all of those desires were just the yetzer hara talking to me as if it was me. Once i clarified for myself what it was that "I" really wanted, it was much easier to reject anything that didn't fit in to my real (logical) desires.