hoping wrote on 21 Jul 2009 13:51:
B"H I am doing well.
I have been following the discussion on GMA's thread. I can only talk from my own experience and not from a general perspective so I would like to post my feelings here.
When I discovered this thread, I was drawn by the feeling that it would help me finally beat back the Y"H that I have been fighting for the majority of my life. Aside from that particular issue, I viewed myself as a pretty solid Ben Torah. Even as I initially tried to implement some of the attitudes that I learned from this site and from 12-step, it was mainly as a 'trick' to overcome the Y"H. What I realized with the help of Hashem, was that I was working backwards. The more fundamental and in ways the more important issue was addressing the internal Chisronos that I am now willing to acknowledge. Understandably, there are times that habit pulls me to act out and I have to fight with the Y"H, but essentially, my battle is on a different plane. I am no expert in the 12 steps, but the concept of 'letting go and letting G-d' is utterly profound and utterly simple at the same time. Not easy, but simple. It is this Yesod that I constantly go back to whenever I am feeling stuck. This is also in my mind the cornerstone of Emuna Peshuta. There is a long Tefilla from the Ohr Lashamayim that focuses initially on acknowledging the involvement of HKB"H in every aspect of our lives, then leads to a Bakasha that we should be aware of it, and only at the very end does the Tefila focus on success in Limud Torah (almost like a tefilla written for the beginning of the 12 steps). This focus on dealing with fundamental Emuna issues is not, in my mind, a medicine that I take until I am cured from whatever is plaguing me, it is a lifelong approach to that, with Hashem's help, can allow me to deal with the Y"h in a healthy manner.
I don't know if this post will benefit anyone else, but it helped me crystalize some of my own thoughts.
Holy Rebbe Hoping,
From here on u may consider me nura one of your talmidim. Boh hoping vhemidum al achas
BTW did u know, someone showed me that there is a beautiful maymar from the Ramchal in the sefer otsros ramchal called the sod hakeevoy "secret of hoping" take a look. Very very fitting for you and very germain to our struggle, My holy Rebbe;)
If u pm me your email address I will send u a pdf copy!!
The smallest and humblest amongst your talmidim
Noorah