I'm reading through some of Gibbor's thread (called "home of Gibbor120")--it's mamash amazing, he has great divrei Torah...and on Page 15, I found something that really helped about the idea behind self-esteem: it is self-acceptance:
WMP and dov, I agree with both of you! I'm still working on my understanding of this, but here's the way I see it right now.
I think you guys are indeed arguing semantics. Dr sorotzkin says essentially exactly what WMP is saying. People with low self-esteem also have as a counterbalance a feeling of superiority. He illustrates this with a case he had of a fellow who had the lowest self-esteem he's ever seen. One day the patient admitted that he sometimes feels greater than G-d. The Dr wasn't surprised in the least. The lowest self-esteem needs a counter balance of the greatest feelings of grandiosity.
As far as what dov writes about accepting himself and realizing that G-d loves him no matter what. That is the foundation of true self-esteem. I have seen this written by (I think) R Twerski and R Zelig Pliskin. My true value is in the fact that Hashem created me, not in what I can do. I think I am finally starting to understand it and I think that's what dov is talking about.
If my self esteem comes from the fact that I always get up on time for shul, what if I'm late one day. If it's because I'm a great basketball player, what if I have a bad game? If it's because I'm a great baal tefillah, what if I mess up a tune? If it's because I'm smart, what if I meet someone smarter than me?
It's this type of false self-esteem that creates pride (the kind dov is weary of). We love ourselves because of x, y, or z. We try to be better to make ourselves feel better. The driving force is really that we feel awful about ourselves (low self-esteem). Once we have self-acceptance (what dov mentioned) we can look at ourselves honestly and not feel prideful about our achievements (or awful about our failures). When we don't accept ourselves, we don't accept our achievements either, so we are driven to acheive more... to boost our self-esteem, but it doesn't work. We need to accept ourselves "just the way we are", then and only then do we have a shot at true self-esteem.
So I think you are both right... that's my 2 cents anyway.
BTW I highly recommend all of Dr Sorotzkins stuff. You can find it here drsorotzkin.com/ . The stuff on perfectionism is especially relevant to this discussion.
That really struck home for me. Self-esteem is a misnomer. It's not esteem...because no matter how great of a person I am, I'm always going to be able to find a reason why I'm worthless. It's self-acceptance, that Hashem has made me the way I am and I'm giving myself up to a higher power.
It's living without regret. It's living while focusing on the good htings, both in myself and others (and accepting other Jews). It's about losing insecurity.
There's no reason to be insecure, because tatte is here and tatte will provide for me.
It's about being thankful for what I have without complaining. Baruch Hashem, I have so many things to be thankful for.
It's about not letting my mother guilt me about the smallest things (oh no! I lost my graduation tassel! How could I???). It's about keeping stuff in perspective, and accepting myself.
I know what it is intellectually, but I'm having difficulty internalizing the conception. Maybe it'll happen over time.
Thoughts?