laagvokeles wrote on 05 Apr 2011 18:39:
alexeliezer wrote on 05 Apr 2011 18:31:
Response to Laagvokeles:
Knowing that I therefore couldn't take even one "drink" remains an important extra motivation not to gaze
no 12 steps needed for that והלא מקרא מלא הוא: ולא תתורו וכו
alexeliezer wrote on 05 Apr 2011 18:31:
Equally important for me was accepting that I was powerless over the addiction and turning over management of my lust to Hashem.
no 12 steps needed
יצרו של אדם מתגבר עליו בכל יום להמיתו ואילו אין הקב"ה עוזרו אינו יכול לו
Yosef Hatzadik wrote on 31 Mar 2011 19:39:
alexeliezer wrote on 31 Mar 2011 19:16:
To be honest, I did not feel qualified to help because I did not follow the whole 12-step program.
GYE is NOT
SA!!!
We are NOT a program based on the 12 Steps. It is ONE of MANY tools which are recommended as available to those who need them.
(Even Dov, GYE's greatest 12 Stepper, says so!) Your describing another method of getting free, a method which actually worked for you, is
VERY MUCH APPRECIATED!!!! Yup, "the 12 steps" is not GYE, SA is not GYE, and so you can take a nice, relaxing shower now. Chill, brother.
When the ARIz"l-solution guy above shares with us that he would talk to Hashem directly about his lust and schmutz use, he was accepting that he does not have the power to overcome it. Period. He admitted that he needed Hashem to help him out.
This is completely different from the frum line we all say that "of course, every breath we take is a miracle and we need Hashem for it!" No. That is not anything like the first step of "the 12 steps" - the twelve steps only work if they are
honest - but the frum line of emunah and frumkeit work just fine even if we don't really believe them. Hey - didn't all of us say those things and even teach them to others?
While we were still acting out our lust? We obviously had a problem
using our emunah.
Could it be that we didn't
really believe that schmutz was
truly bad for us (no matter what the halocha stated)? Our guts - didn't they tell us differently - that it was sweet and in our very best interest? What about our seichel that told us it was the stupidest idea to act on that lust? Surely we kept doing it because we believed that we
could tolerate more of it - till after we got the job over with, of course... Then it always becomes clear, the lie...till the nect time when we again 'forget'. Why?
Could it be that we also did not
really believe that Hashem knew what's
really best for us? That He was not really our Best Friend of all? Weren't we sure - while planning and searching for schmutz and checking out that pretty woman's image, etc. - that the sweetness of the porn, masturbation and whatever else we liked to do was really, really
good for us? Did we doubt that b'sha'as mayseh? How strong was the doubt. if it was there?
Looking at it as "the YH" actually removes personal responsibility for us. People like to say that calling it an illness does that. Really, I see it the opposite way: recovery says there are things wrong with the way I approach and respond to women, people in general, Hashem, life, and how things make me feel, that leads me to need to use lust. The resonsibility I bear in recovery and as an addict, is in recovering the sanity Hashem made me with as a kid (or before).
That's all the steps are about. Nowhere in the steps does it talk about
self-esteem, and nowhere in the steps does it talk about
lust - except in the 1st step. As R' Elozar ben Durdaya discovered,
he had to bring the 1st step with him. Even
Hashem was not going to do that for him - only the addict (and I do believe he was an addict like Par'oh was, as well) can do that. He is a
yoreh chato'im baderech - sometimes by showing us (yoreh deyah), sometimes by throwing us (yaro y'yareh)....but that's all he does till we take the personal responsibility and admit - if we are addicts and truly sick - that nothing will work to fix us but Hashem Himself. Not tehillim, not learning Torah, not sex with the wife, not tevillah, not tikun klali - nothing but Retzon Atzmuso Yisborach, period.
That is why the 1st step is the only
real hisarusa d'l'sata in the program. The rest has nothing to do with lust, drinking, whetever (the problem), and is all about the solution. Any program of action that focuses on being a kodosh or doing teshuvah by constant vigilance to
avoid the drinking, lusting, etc., is doomed. Even though it is definitely a mitzvah to stop treifing ourselves up and being kedoshim. That doesn't make it the correct thing to do for us, right now.
Too long a post again. Whoever reads it, drop me a line or PM and yell at me about how wrong I am if you like. But I do not want to create machlokes. For those who are afraid of "blind 12 step-is the-only-way" disease, I am with you. 12 steps
cannot be the only way! And I am always available to help you dispell that shitttah and keep room for the "ARIz"l program", taphsic, hypnosis, or any other program that has at least some evidence.
But I do see the 12 steps as a program of living yourself itno right thinking - very akin to the
words and
spirit of "Na'aseh veNishmah". Simple honesty that usually leads to sanity. And I have experienced honesty as a powerful tool for recovery, for those who need it. So I'd suggest it to anyone who has 100% made up their mind that he or she is in deep trouble and cannot get out of any addiction. It has been working for me in every respect so far - I believe you'd do the same.
Love and respect to y'all -
and believing that 'alexeliezer's eitza will help many,
Dov