L'zecher nishamos Rav Yochanon Motel ben Rav Ephraim and Moras Esther Leah bas Rav Yehudah Yoseph B"H
The Salant Center
Mussar - A Healing Spirit for the Heart and Soul
THE WISDOM OF THE TALMUD
The Talmud (Shabbos 86) relates that after HaShem gave the Torah to Moshe at Mount Sinai, the satan asked HaShem, "Where is the Torah?" HaShem responded, "The Torah is on the earth." The satan descended to earth and searched for the Torah. He looked on the land and in the sea but he could not find the Torah. He ascended to Heaven and told HaShem that he could not find the Torah on the earth.
HaShem told him, "Moshe has the Torah." He descended to the earth and asked Moshe, "Do you have the Torah?" Moshe responded, "Who am I, that HaShem would give me the Torah?" At that point, HaShem asked Moshe, "Why are you denying the truth?" Moshe responded, "HaShem, You delight with the Torah every day. How could I say that I have the Torah?" HaShem then stated, "Since you minimize yourself, the Torah will be called by your name." Accordingly, the Torah is called Toras Moshe, i.e., the Torah of Moshe.
Yet, this passage seems to be contradictory. HaShem gave the Torah to Moshe. Yet, Moshe told the satan that he did not have the Torah. In light of his denial, why did HaShem call the Torah, Toras Moshe?
Moshe was the humblest man on the face of the earth. When satan asked him the location of the Torah, it did not occur to Moshe to claim the Torah was in his possession. He knew that his knowledge of Torah was but a drop in the ocean compared to the infinite and absolute knowledge of HaShem. Therefore, he said he did not have the Torah. Meaning, in contrast to HaShem, he had a mere superficial understanding of the Torah.
Moshe was the greatest of our prophets, receiving the Torah directly from HaShem at Mount Sinai. Nevertheless, he did consider himself a master of Torah! In fact, his humility was the merit upon which he received the Torah, as well as, the reason why HaShem calls it Toras Moshe.
The transmission of Torah depends not on intelligence, but rather on one's humility. May we follow Moshe's humble path, so that we will merit our share in the holy Torah.
[Based on the commentary of the Sifsei Chaim]
TODAY: Whenever you succeed or accomplish something, say, "Thank you HaShem for helping me."
eMussar" Copyright © 2010 by Rabbi Zvi Miller and The Salant Foundation