It's very nice to read your post, Mousy guy! Thanks for the chizzuk and for reminding me to stick with the spiritual growth over everything else. And here is another tirade....it just fell out again....
One suggestion, and I do not know if it's a chiddush to you at all. But it is to some others and is very precious to me:
I have never - I mean never - actually been koneh any middah tova (or ra'ah), nor have I ever been koneh any freedom from anything (or bondage to anything) by thinking it over deeply or by learning and chazering anything. And I have learned the big seforim, b"H.
Rather, the only way that anything I have ever learned has made any change in my life, is through my behavior. This is what I mean when I quote, "You can't think yourself into right living. You can only live yourself into right thinking." "Just get lost in living, and you will find yourself in G-d," as a friend of mine used to say.
This is what the steps are, contrary to what many of the philosophers on this forum have written. They are not a philosophy of living at all - they are steps to take. They have so little to do with our hashkofah and everything to do with our behavior. Figure them out and nothing happens. Nothing. It says, "These are the steps we took." One will 'know' them, 'darshen' on them, and 'understand' them...and will remain the smartest drunk (or pervert) in the world. In other words, just another drunk.
I do not digress. You are saying good: the ikkar is building an awareness and closeness to Hashem, as you wrote. That surely is what it is all about! There is nothing else than that, and it is the only real answer to our addiction. But it does not come first - it comes last.
I bear witness that the only way I got any of that (and I have some of it, b"H) is this: by not masturbating and not getting lost in sexual fantasy.
Not very glamorous, is it? Doesn't sound like much. And really it's not. Yet guess what? As any of us people who are chronic slippers know, it is actually impossible for us! By getting the help I needed to just do that - stay clean one day at a time even if my behind falls off, I was made able to recieve a gift of understanding. That understanding makes it a lot easier. And life becomes much more fun, too. Till that happens...not so much fun. But there's the rub: we need to surrender the acting out even if it makes us miserable - or else we will still use it even after He gives us the big gifts of sobriety. So many complain that they 'it hurts'. So? Of course the first few months will hurt! They 'fall' and want 'chizzuk'. Why? is it all about 'feeling better'? The answer is yes - for them, it is...and that's why they will be back at the magazine rack or the porn site in a week or two.
And that is what taking the 1st step is. Giving it up because we can't afford not to. The comes all the rest, and the understanding comes after (most of) them.
If anyone thinks they are clear on what I am saying, then please do not think about it any more! Just do it. Get the help you need to stop. If you believe that you might get better by going to SA meetings, then please, please, quit being so afraid of "being seen in an SA meeting by another frum yid". This is your life, your future, your everything. If you are an addict, then without sobriety you will drown. Give up the kovod and the fear and do for yourself.
"Nura b'veis Amrom!!" - look! He wasn't even an addict! And he took the extreme measures necesarry for one reason: he was not a foolish ba'al gayvoh and he put his real life ahead of his 'image'. May I (and we all) always be zoche to do the very same!
All I am here to say is that it generally does not come to us the other way around. If it could work that old way, then it would have worked for us ten years ago! And that other way around is so very tempting to us cerebral b'nei Torah. But it is shekker vechozov, and stupid. I know you are not meaning to suggest that, but I just felt like trying to speak out and make that point very clear.
Some - especially the more romantically religious among us, who relish "being generals in waging the big milchomoh on the yetzer hora" - will secretly feel insulted and want to brand me as a defector from Torah, c"v. But - who is the one still masturbating on the bathroom floor? Hmm?
OK. I'm cooked....stick a fork into me if you like!
Have a great Sh"k!!