ontheedgeman wrote on 17 May 2012 20:26:
it's true... sometimes these forums can actually be a kind of acting out for me, in the sense of indulging and reliving my fantasies or my aveiros. why talk about the 12 steps of recovery when we can talk about how close we came to acting out, how we fell, how we can set up this and this geder.
step 1 is "we admitted we were powerless...". does that mean wear sunglasses? close one eye? Walk backwards? jump in a mikveh, take cold showers?
I guess my question is: how do 99% of these posts deal with the actual way out of addiction as opposed to more failed attempts to control.
What am I powerless over? I thought it was one thing, but it's more than that. I was powerless over alcohol. That I could admit and it's been 18 months and I haven't looked back. My cravings for booze are gone. but now my cravings have transferred to other things.
Strange as it may sound to addicts who are doing really well with the 12 steps, there may be other ways to get better. And I need to believe that fighting - though it is certainly just plain stupid and often horribly destructive to families and lives -
might actually work for many people, too. I'd sooner suggest they are not addicts, at all...but we do not have a monopoly on recovery nor on "quitting".
True, the lying and denial are rife in the ranks of those who who look down or hesitate to really use the steps, who often say things like:
1- "Really opening up to another real person
just doesn't work for me" (really we are just ashamed, chicken, or know that admitting it to a real person
will jeopardize their ability to keep acting out their lust with the shred of 'self-respect' we have left!)
2- "Use my real first name?! Too dangerous." (is my life in the toilet? My real name is all over the place,
and much of my dirt. Veiter chicken...
3- "It'd be a chillul Hashem for me to go to a meeting with all those goyim there." (More chicken on the menu...this time the chicken begins to taste funny. If
Rav Amram Chasida ["Noorah b'veis Amram!"] would have used
that excuse [he obviously didn't!], we wouldn't have
had an Amram Chasidah!)
4- "Iv'e been clean for a week after plotzing for more porn and masturbating for five years...and here is how I did it: ...." (Check please!)
..and lots of other goofy things. So?
They might actually be right!! And besides, GYE is not only for addicts. As i repeat so often, contrary to what rav Avrohom Twerski implies he believes, i submit to you that a minority of the people who use GYE are addicts at all. There is also a YH for porn because it feels good, period. Nothing to do with living a double life, and they really
can stop. This is normal people. There are still a lot of them, even in 2012!
Step 2 - "Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity". how many posts on this site are about the awesome Power of H" to restore us to sanity? I thought I did step 2 but I applied it only to alcohol. Eventually I came to believe that only massages could restore me to sanity. My step 2 was broken.
Step 3 - "made a decision to turn our will and lives over to Gcd..." truth is, despite being "sober" for 18 months, I have trouble doing this. how can the same Gcd who gave my wife cancer, seemingly cure it, only to have it relapse (and now finally in remission) how can He be trusted? He has blessed me a million times over since then... to be sure... but deep down I have that fear and sadness and mistrust... That's a real major crack in my emunah that I just haven't gotten over and I don't know how I can. more meetings, more discussions. tears come to the eyes as I think about recovery in this context. I want to have full emunah, I have a bookshelf of books on Emunah...
anyhow those are my thoughts. let's talk about the steps to the way out, no?
What sanity shmanity? The majority of people who look at porn or masturbate once in a while are not insane, but just stupid. Or just lack enough yir'as Shomayim. Maybe they don't need an infusion of sanity, but just a pat on the back and something to keep them busy....maybe. Who are we to know? Only trial and error really prove anything.
Stay cool, man. It is working for you? It ain't easy to be simple? You falter at times and wonder where He is and what He is doing with you? Nu. We are not G-d. And you are probably doing just fine. It works of you work it.
Somebody said that a big difference between me and G-d is that
He doesn't go around all day thinking He's
me!
Give your wife a hug and a kiss, love her as best you can. You deserve it. In that, you will find a place for G-d and it'll grow from there, maybe. It does for me.