Jooboy wrote on 29 Dec 2010 02:07:
My 2cents..
I don't suggest the ben durdaya route to teshuva. Don't get me wrong, it is certainly effective. The problem is that most people can't do it because as the gemara concludes he died. To on our own try to effect such a large change out of sheer willpower is basically fatal. Making a decision to let God run the show of our life and take it one day at a time surrendering our lust works and is quite a bit safer
OK, so here is some MaHaRa"L-esque stuff for you:
He died. He did Teshuvah, and he died. Which came first, I wonder. Maybe they happenned together. Maybe they always do...
"
Ein haTorah nikneiss, ella l'mi sh'meimis es atzmo oleha" Hmmm. What
good does the kinyan do for
anyone if the guy's dead?! Doesn't it say "
ha'omer ein li ella Torah (he will not do mitzvos, just learn Torah) - afilu Torah ein lo!" - and it means even if he is l'Shem Shomayim. But here this guy is dying and will not do any more mitzvos?
OK, maybe not an eiseneh kashyeh, but you get my drift, no?
So we all understand that "
mi sh'meimis es atzmo aleha" means something other than physically dropping dead. Right?
I do believe R' EBD
physically dropped dead. ChaZa"L say he did. However, the lesson and avodah for us may be different:
We really need to die if we are to do Teshuvah. We need to die if we are to get sober. And we all know what that dying is about, I think. It means that what we want so much that we feel certain that
we are going to die without it - we need to eventually give that up. To surrender. Because we must eventually choose between living for
lust, or living for
ourselves.
Huh? Living for lust? That's easy! That's being selfish! We are great at that, no?
Well, no. Not addicts. We even failed at that! Our selfishness ruins everything for us. And so, we are shocked to discover that we cannot even
live for ourselves by giving into lust! Our selfishness doesn't even
work! If
that doesn't work, we wonder, then what
does?! Gevalt, what's a yunger mahn supposed to do? :
At the end of our shameful, dark, and slimy road we discover that sticking with lust - the thing we trusted most powerfully and privately and consistently of all things - even Hashem - is actually our greatest enemy of all and
will ruin our lives until we will lose possession of our
selves any more! Uh-oh.
That's the 1st step.
If we are lucky, we turn our backs on our best friend and betray lust. (It betrayed us first, anyhow.) We jump off the roller-coaster ride. The attendant (our body and screwed up brain) screams "Hey! You can't do that! What, are you nuts!?"
And then the people we meet in recovery help us out by counseling us to respond to the attendant that he is right, and to admit to him that we
are nuts. He stops hollering. We can't do it alone.
That's the 2nd step.
Then we get a chance to start allowing a Power Greater than ourselves to restore us to sanity - meaning we obviously
lost our sanity somewhere along the way. Maybe He can find it for us? We - who were frum - worshiped the wrong stuff, and for a long time...no wonder things got so ugly.
That's the rest of the 2nd step, for me.
Anyway, enough ranting from me...Happy Shovevim!